Google reviews badge

30 October 2026by Soulmed

Is a Smaller, Better Located Tenancy More Valuable Than a Larger One?

A practice has shortlisted two premises. One is smaller and closer to the people it hopes to serve. The other offers more floor area but a less convenient journey. It is tempting to choose between them using a simple rule: location matters most, or more space gives the practice room to grow.

Neither rule explains what these particular premises would enable. A smaller tenancy may be valuable when it supports the intended service and makes attendance more practical. A larger one may be valuable when the additional area has a clear purpose. Both propositions need evidence.

The comparison should start with the practice’s required functions, then examine the specific benefit of the location and the obligations of each option. This is a planning framework, not a property valuation or a forecast of patient demand.

Define what better located means for this practice

A location can be prominent without being convenient for the patients who will use it. Describe the proposed advantage in terms that can be investigated: a more practical public transport journey, a clearer arrival route, proximity to an existing patient community or easier access for staff.

Avoid using general foot traffic as a substitute for understanding the service. A practice whose patients book planned appointments may assess the surrounding street differently from a business relying on passing trade. The relevant question is how the location supports the particular patient and practitioner journey.

Choose a few concrete observations to check at appropriate times. Walk the approach, investigate the available transport and parking arrangements, and consider how someone unfamiliar with the area would find the entrance. These observations inform the comparison; they do not establish commercial demand or guarantee attendance.

Set a functional threshold before comparing advantages

Identify the activities the premises must support for the proposed service to work appropriately. Include consultation and treatment needs where relevant, essential support functions, patient participation, privacy and staff work. Relevant professionals need to assess the applicable requirements.

If a tenancy cannot support an essential function, a good address does not resolve that limitation. A practice should not count a corridor as storage or assume that a staff task can permanently occupy a patient space simply to make a smaller option appear viable.

This threshold keeps the comparison honest. It also prevents the larger tenancy receiving automatic credit for rooms that have no defined purpose. Both properties need to support the same intended practice before their additional advantages can be judged sensibly.

Look at usable relationships, not only advertised area

Floor area does not explain how the rooms relate to one another. A compact tenancy with useful proportions may support a coherent arrangement. A larger one may contain an awkward section or fixed elements that limit the ways its area can be used.

Ask the design team to test the required functions in each premises. Look at the relationship between clinical rooms, staff support and arrival rather than counting labelled rooms alone. Keep the investigation at an appropriate preliminary level until important building information is established.

A hypothetical consulting practice might find that both properties accommodate its confirmed sessions, but only one provides a suitable place for administrative work between appointments. That is a specific distinction worth investigating. It is more useful than assuming that one property must work better because its advertised area is greater.

Give spare space a named purpose

Additional area can create opportunities, but an opportunity should have a plausible connection to the practice plan. Describe whether the space would serve a confirmed future activity, improve a current support function or remain unallocated while the business develops.

Keep those categories separate. A confirmed service expansion deserves a different discussion from an idea that depends on future recruitment or uncertain demand. Ask what the practice would need to know before committing the extra area to that use.

The aim is not to dismiss growth. It is to avoid paying attention only to an attractive future layout while neglecting the ordinary working week. A larger tenancy becomes more compelling when the owner can explain what the additional area will support, when it is likely to be needed and what remains uncertain.

Consider the cost of each workable option

Once both premises have been tested against the functional brief, compare their financial implications with the relevant advisers. Keep fitout, ongoing occupancy and transition costs visible as separate categories. Use a consistent period and scope agreed with those advisers.

The smaller option may have a higher rent relative to area while requiring less total fitted space. The larger option may offer area that the practice does not initially use. Neither observation settles the overall comparison because terms, condition, required work and business circumstances differ.

Do not invent a value for extra patient visits or assume the address will produce additional income. If a business case relies on that benefit, identify the evidence and professional input needed to assess it. The design review can explain physical capability; it cannot establish the commercial return on its own.

Use trade-offs that people can understand

Prepare a short comparison in plain language. For each premises, describe the arrival advantage, fit with the required functions, purpose of any additional area, key cost uncertainties and the compromise the practice would accept. Keep observations separate from expectations.

For example, the compact option might offer a simpler journey for a defined group of existing patients while leaving little room for an unconfirmed future service. The larger option might accommodate that service but require further investigation of the arrival experience. These are hypothetical trade-offs, not conclusions about any actual property.

Ask which finding would change the preference. If the answer is whether the smaller tenancy can support an essential staff function, investigate that before debating a minor finish difference. If the answer is whether the extra area has a credible use, refine the practice plan before treating size as an advantage.

Choose the premises whose value you can explain

A useful decision can be summarised without calling one property universally better. State why the preferred premises supports the intended care, which location benefit has been checked, which compromise is accepted and what conditions still need resolution with advisers.

Share that account with the team responsible for design and delivery. It explains the reasons behind the choice and helps protect them as the layout develops. An important arrival advantage or staff function should not disappear quietly during later cost or design changes.

A smaller, better located tenancy can be more valuable to a particular practice, but only when better located has a clear meaning and the essential functions fit. Compare one verified location benefit with one clearly defined spatial trade-off. That gives the next premises discussion a practical basis, grounded in patients, practitioners and the service you intend to provide.